Bella’s Cafe & Catering – New Bern, NC

For one of the most beloved coffee shops in New Bern, NC, Bella’s Cafe & Catering is a real treasure. Set on 323 Middle Street in the heart of historic downtown Craven County’s county seat, this charming, locally owned coffee shop captures the essence of a true hometown gathering spot — with baked-on-site goods, locally roasted coffee, and the kind of warm, welcoming character that makes every visit feel like coming home. Click on the pictures below to get a feel for Bella’s Cafe & Catering before you go — or to relive the visit after.

A Hometown Cafe in Historic Downtown

Bella’s Cafe & Catering anchors one of the most rewarding corners of downtown New Bern. The owner once described it as the realization of a longtime dream — “It has always been a dream to own my own coffee shop, and now that dream has come true with the opening of Bella’s Cafe & Catering” — and that warmth comes through every part of the experience.

The cafe is genuinely a gathering place: locals sit down for a drink and stay for a conversation, regulars are greeted by name, and even first-time visitors quickly come to feel like part of the community. The atmosphere is the kind that’s harder and harder to find in modern coffee shops — neither overly trendy nor stuffy, just welcoming, comfortable, and rooted in the neighborhood.

Locally Roasted Coffee and Baked-on-Site Goods

The signature draws at Bella’s are the locally roasted coffee and the homemade baked goods made fresh on-site. The coffee program is thoughtful and approachable — espresso drinks, drip coffee, specialty seasonal lattes (including a beloved lavender latte), Italian sodas, and a wide range of teas all available throughout the day.

On the bakery side, the lineup rotates seasonally but typically includes:

• Cinnamon rolls — soft, gooey, and perfectly spiced
• Pumpkin muffins — seasonal and bursting with warm flavor
• Cheddar biscuits — made fresh and typically available only in the mornings
• Oatmeal cups with chocolate chips
• A variety of other muffins, pastries, scones, and quick breads

The aroma of fresh-baked goods greets you the moment you walk in — and the rotating selection gives regulars a reason to come back week after week.

Signature Sandwiches and Cozy Comfort

Beyond coffee and baked goods, Bella’s serves a thoughtful lineup of gourmet sandwiches, salads, and warm comfort dishes. A standout favorite is the “Raisin’ The Roof” — a sandwich on cinnamon raisin bread with ham, gooey brie cheese, balsamic glaze, and honey mustard. It’s the kind of unexpected, perfectly balanced combination that captures the creative spirit of the kitchen.

Other beloved menu items include:

• Chicken Caesar wraps (regular and grilled)
• Quiche of the day
• Loaded potato soup
• Gluten-free options — including a gluten-free BLT that the staff is particularly careful with for guests with allergies
• Fruit smoothies — a hit with kids and adults alike

The staff is known for being attentive to allergies and dietary needs, making the cafe a safe and welcoming option for visitors with food sensitivities.

A Welcoming Indoor and Outdoor Setting

Bella’s offers both indoor and outdoor seating — making it a flexible spot for any kind of visit. The indoor space features a long bench seat lined with pillows, plus tables and counter-style seating that give the cafe its distinctive, cozy vibe. The outdoor seating is perfect for warmer weather and the more leisurely mornings that downtown New Bern was made for.

The setting works equally well for working remotely, reading a book, catching up with friends, or just slowing down for an hour with a coffee and a homemade pastry. It’s one of those rare spots that genuinely accommodates whatever kind of visit you’re hoping to have.

Good to Know

• Address: 323 Middle Street, New Bern, NC 28560
• Style: Locally owned, hometown coffee shop and cafe
• Coffee program: Locally roasted; full espresso and drip menu; specialty lattes including a beloved lavender latte; teas, Italian sodas, smoothies
• Baked goods: Made fresh on-site; rotating selection of cinnamon rolls, pumpkin muffins, cheddar biscuits, oatmeal cups, and more
• Food highlights: “Raisin’ The Roof” sandwich, chicken Caesar wraps, loaded potato soup, quiche, gluten-free options
• Seating: Indoor and outdoor seating
• Best for: Coffee lovers, families, remote workers, allergy-conscious diners, and visitors looking for a warm, welcoming hometown vibe
• Pair with: A visit to Bear City Fudge Company, a stroll through downtown New Bern, and a stop at the Birthplace of Pepsi
• Located at 323 Middle Street in downtown New Bern, NC

A New Bern Highlight

Bella’s Cafe & Catering is the kind of stop that genuinely captures what makes downtown New Bern such a rewarding place to spend a morning. The locally roasted coffee, the baked-on-site pastries, the creative sandwiches like the “Raisin’ The Roof,” the genuine warmth of the staff, and the welcoming combination of indoor and outdoor seating all add up to one of the most consistently delightful cafe experiences in Craven County. Whether you’re catching up with friends, settling in with a book, working remotely, or just stopping in for a quick coffee and a cinnamon roll, this is one of the most rewarding cafe stops you can make anywhere in North Carolina.

---

---

Resources

Bella’s Cafe & Catering Website

Bella’s Cafe & Catering Facebook

---

Location

---

Social Media

---

---